Never Always, Never NeverNever Always,
Never Never
The BookAI CreativeAI ProjectsChatNewsletter
Buy the Book
Never Always,
Never Never.

Strategic Marketing in an AI World.
By Patrick Gilbert.

Explore

  • The Book
  • The Author
  • Free Chapter
  • Buy
  • Resources

Connect

  • Newsletter
  • Learn
  • AI Projects
  • Blog
  • Chat with the Book
  • Subscribe

Stay Connected

Get updates, bonus frameworks, and new AI project showcases.

© 2026 Patrick Gilbert. All rights reserved.

AdVenture MediaContact
Brands8 min readNovember 22, 2026

Erewhon Sells a $20 Smoothie by Selling Something Else

Patrick Gilbert

Patrick Gilbert

CEO of AdVenture Media. Author of Never Always, Never Never.

Erewhon's Strawberry Skin Glaze smoothie sells approximately 40,000 units per month at around $20 each. That's roughly $760,000 in monthly gross sales for a single blended drink at a grocery chain with about 10 locations in Los Angeles. No national distribution. No Super Bowl ads. No loyalty points.

The obvious question is how. The more useful question is why, and the answer reveals something important about how status, scarcity, and emotional advertising effectiveness combine to build a brand that conventional marketing models struggle to explain.

The Smoothie Is Not the Product

Erewhon does not primarily sell a $20 smoothie. It sells a socially visible proof of participation in a scarce Los Angeles wellness culture. The smoothie makes that promise tangible.

This distinction matters enormously. If Erewhon were simply selling a premium blended beverage, it would compete on ingredients, nutrition, and taste. Its price would need justification on those dimensions, and $20 would look indefensible next to a $7 Jamba Juice. But that is not the competition Erewhon is actually in.

Launched in 2022 in collaboration with Hailey Bieber, the Strawberry Skin Glaze is limited, celebrity-linked, visually distinctive, and available only inside a small network of stores in Calabasas, Pacific Palisades, Santa Monica, and Pasadena. Each of those constraints is a feature, not a limitation. The drink is photographable. It signals that you were there. It connects you, however thinly, to Bieber's aesthetic and the broader cultural moment she occupies.

That emotional and symbolic value carries a portion of the price that ingredients alone cannot justify. This is exactly the kind of mechanism Patrick Gilbert examines in Never Always, Never Never: the idea that emotional advertising works not by persuading people rationally, but by creating feelings that attach to a brand and persist over time.

Celebrity Collaborations as Earned-Media Engines

Celebrity partnerships at Erewhon are structurally different from standard influencer endorsements. The celebrity does not simply appear in an advertisement. The celebrity helps design a scarce, purchasable, and photographable product.

That architecture solves a problem most brands cannot. Normally, awareness and revenue sit on opposite sides of a transaction: you spend money to generate awareness, and then you try to convert that awareness into sales. Erewhon collapses the two. The object generating attention is also sold at retail. The promotion generates revenue directly.

Collaborations since the Hailey Bieber launch illustrate how deliberate the pattern is:

  • Bella Hadid brought ingredients connected to her wellness and nonalcoholic-beverage brand.
  • Emma Chamberlain contributed a coffee-based shake tied to her Chamberlain Coffee brand.
  • Cactus Plant Flea Market priced its collaboration at $22 and extended the concept into co-branded apparel, pushing the product into fashion retail territory.
  • Sabrina Carpenter launched the "Short n' Sweet" smoothie in 2024, timed to her album campaign and tapping directly into a pop-culture moment.

Each partner brings a distinct audience, a distinct aesthetic, and a distinct set of cultural associations. None of them simply lend their name to an existing product. The product is the collaboration, which means every launch is a new cultural event rather than a repeat of the previous one.

What results is what the research on earned media consistently describes: coverage, social posts, fan visits, and user-generated content that would cost far more if purchased through conventional advertising. Erewhon receives that distribution without buying equivalent reach in paid channels.

Scarcity as a Brand Mechanic

Limited-time availability is not incidental to this strategy. It is the strategy.

In Never Always, Never Never, the tension between physical availability and brand positioning is a recurring theme. Byron Sharp's research, developed through the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, argues that mass brands grow by making themselves as easy to buy as possible. More presence, more prominence, more access. For a brand like Coca-Cola, as the book discusses, being everywhere at the moment of purchase is the competitive advantage.

The playbook at Erewhon runs in the opposite direction, and it works precisely because Erewhon is not a mass brand. Its physical availability is intentionally constrained. Ten locations in Los Angeles. Ingredients and recipes that change with each celebrity partner. Products that disappear when the collaboration ends.

For a mass grocery brand, that model would be catastrophic. Scarcity reduces trial, frustrates customers, and suppresses volume. But for a status brand, scarcity performs a different function. It makes access meaningful. If you can get the Sabrina Carpenter smoothie, that tells a story about you: you live in or can get to the right part of Los Angeles, you are aware enough of the cultural moment to know the drink exists, and you were motivated enough to actually go. The inconvenience is part of the value.

These constraints have limits, of course. Scarcity only works as long as it feels aspirational rather than merely annoying. Erewhon's model depends on that balance holding.

The Visual Identity Problem That Isn't a Problem

Erewhon's smoothies are pink drinks, vivid colors, and recognizable names attached to celebrities their customers already follow. That is not an accident of aesthetics. It is a deliberate answer to a distribution problem.

When your advertising budget is limited relative to your competitors, your products need to do some of the awareness work themselves. A smoothie that photographs well and carries a recognizable celebrity name functions as a distinctive brand asset in a customer's social feed. Every photo posted from inside an Erewhon store is a piece of organic media. Every tagged post showing the Strawberry Skin Glaze in someone's hand extends the collaboration's reach beyond the initial celebrity announcement.

This is the social-first model operating at its most efficient. Products are designed to be shared. Stores are designed to be visited and documented. Collaborations are timed to cultural moments that already have momentum. Erewhon does not need to generate all of its own attention because it attaches to attention that already exists.

Chapter 15 of Never Always, Never Never makes the case that emotional advertising works in part because feelings transfer from the emotional experience to the brand. When a Sabrina Carpenter fan walks into Erewhon during her album campaign and buys the smoothie she created, the emotional context of that fan's existing enthusiasm for the artist gets attached to the Erewhon brand. That is not a minor marketing benefit. It is an extremely efficient form of emotional vs rational advertising where the emotion is borrowed from a cultural moment rather than manufactured from scratch.

What Byron Sharp Would Say (And Where He'd Be Wrong)

Byron Sharp's growth model, grounded in decades of research at the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, holds that brands grow primarily by reaching as many category buyers as possible, building mental availability, and making themselves easy to buy. For most brands, the prescription is clear: invest in broad reach, consistency, and physical distribution.

Apply that framework directly to Erewhon and it looks like a brand violating most of the rules. Limited distribution. No national presence. Products that disappear. Prices that exclude most grocery shoppers by design.

But Sharp's framework was built on the buying patterns of mass-market categories. Luxury goods, status products, and experience brands operate under different demand dynamics. The double jeopardy law, which shows that smaller brands suffer lower penetration and lower loyalty, describes what happens when a brand is small in a market where size confers advantage. Erewhon has opted out of that competition entirely. It is not trying to be the biggest grocery chain. It is trying to be the most culturally significant one within a deliberately narrow geography.

This does not mean the law of physical availability is wrong. It means the law applies differently depending on what the brand is actually selling. As the chapter on physical availability in Never Always, Never Never notes, any move that limits accessibility comes with a cost, and understanding that tradeoff honestly is the starting point for sound strategy. Erewhon has made the tradeoff consciously. Limited footprint supports limited access, which supports status pricing, which funds the celebrity collaboration engine.

The Earned Media Question Nobody Asks

Public sources do not confirm that Erewhon has zero paid advertising budget. Claims to that effect appear in commentary and social media posts, but they are not verified by any financial disclosure from the company. Erewhon is privately held and does not publish its media spend.

What can be said accurately is that Erewhon places unusual emphasis on celebrity partnerships, in-store discovery, limited-time products, and editorial coverage. Whether those channels are supplemented by paid media or not, the visible engine of brand growth is clearly not conventional TV or digital display advertising.

That emphasis produces a specific kind of brand equity. Les Binet and Peter Field's IPA DataBank research consistently shows that emotionally resonant campaigns build longer-lasting brand effects than purely rational or promotional ones. Erewhon's collaborations are emotionally resonant almost by construction: they tap into the fan relationships customers already have with Hailey Bieber, Sabrina Carpenter, or Emma Chamberlain. Rather than manufacturing emotion, the brand positions itself correctly relative to emotion that already exists.

At AdVenture Media, the question of which media channels drive brand equity versus immediate conversion comes up constantly. The honest answer is that most brands underweight the former and overweight the latter, particularly in environments dominated by ROAS-focused measurement. Erewhon's model is an extreme counterexample, one where the brand investment is almost entirely upstream of any direct-response mechanism.

The Takeaway Is Not "Go Build an Erewhon"

Most brands cannot replicate Erewhon's strategy. Celebrity collaboration requires cultural relevance that most brands have not built. Status pricing requires a customer base willing and able to pay it. Geographic concentration that reinforces exclusivity would simply mean failure for a brand whose value proposition depends on convenience.

But the underlying mechanics are transferable in parts.

The insight that the product can carry the marketing is widely applicable. Products designed to be shared, photographed, and discussed are doing marketing work that conventional advertising pays for. The insight that emotion borrowed from cultural context is more efficient than emotion manufactured from scratch is equally applicable. Collaborations with creators, musicians, or even other brands that already have fan relationships give you access to emotional context you did not have to build.

The insight that scarcity and status pricing reinforce each other requires the most caution. It only works if the scarcity is genuine and the status is real. Artificial scarcity without genuine cultural cachet is just poor availability, and your customers will notice.

Perhaps the most underappreciated insight is that physical availability strategy should match your brand positioning. Building a status brand means distributing everywhere cheapens it. Building a mass brand means limiting distribution kills it. These are not universal principles pointing in the same direction. They point in opposite directions depending on what your brand actually is.

Erewhon sells 40,000 units of a single smoothie per month at $20 each not because they found a great smoothie recipe. They found the right answer to a harder question: what does this product mean to the person holding it? Until you can answer that question clearly, the recipe is irrelevant.

---

For more on how emotional advertising drives long-term brand growth, see the chapter on [building mental availability](/learn/guides/how-to-build-mental-availability). For the tension between scarcity and reach, the [brand vs performance marketing](/learn/brand-vs-performance-marketing) framework is a useful starting point. We also covered related dynamics in the [celebrity brand boom](/blog/celebrity-brand-boom) post and in the analysis of [how Rhode Beauty built distinctive assets](/blog/rhode-beauty-marketing) around the same Hailey Bieber cultural moment.

Patrick GilbertPatrick Gilbert

Patrick Gilbert is the CEO of AdVenture Media and author of Never Always, Never Never and the bestselling Join or Die. He has been ranked among the top 5 PPC experts worldwide and has delivered keynotes at Google events across three continents.

More about Patrick →

Enjoyed this?

Subscribe for more articles on strategy, AI, and what's actually working in marketing.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Keep reading

Brands

Rhode Beauty: Hailey Bieber's Masterclass in Distinctive Assets

Rhode hit $212M in revenue with just 10 products and 11% marketing spend. Here's the marketing science behind why it worked.

Strategy

The Celebrity Brand Boom: Distinctiveness or Dilution?

Celebrity brand marketing is booming and declining at the same time. Here's what the data actually says about which celebrity brands win.

Brands

Liquid Death's $1.4B Lesson: Why Distinctiveness Trumps Differentiation

How Liquid Death built a $1.4B water brand through distinctive assets like tallboy cans and punk aesthetics rather than product superiority.